Photography As ART

“Photography As ART” script shows how James creates his art using only light, camera, and optics, in addition to considerable logistical planning, technical experimentation, patience and dedication.

Photography As ART – The ILLUSION series/P5 – Scene 7

April 24 2017 - Photography As ART
Image 40 shows the SCULPTURE GARDEN. Quickly dissolve to a seasonal photo(s) of the Filed Gallery Garden. CUT to a photo of T. Maley


A place you can’t miss on the Vineyard is the Field Gallery in West Tisbury. The galleries garden is the home for the whimsical sculptures by Thomas Maley.

CUT to shots of a few individual sculptures

These playful dancing figures are a joy and James decided to add his own whimsy into the scene, called the SCULPTURE GARDEN.

CUT to a shot of the Sculpture Garden in the summer season. Then CUT to shots of the busy activity close by: The W. Tisbury Market and old Agricultural Center.


The sculptures are all white and I thought all the green seasonal vegetation would only be a distraction (just like clothing would be). It’s also a seasonally busy attraction off the West Tisbury Road. A more tranquil peaceful setting… burrrrr… a white out of a winter snow he felt would be ideal.

CUT to show several snowy scenes easily recognized as Vineyard related.

CUT to a video with a handheld Sharpie drawing an arrow in the direction of the person holding the flash, and a circle where the person holding the coat was located, and dashes in the background with the path taken to avoid footprints in the foreground. DISSOLVE to the clean version of the SCULPTURE GARDEN illusion.

When winter brought the snow, we set out to the location. One assistant for this shoot would hold a flash that would be remotely triggered to highlight the muse. Another assistant was hiding in the background bushes with a coat at the ready to keep the Muse from freezing. My most important directorial input in setting up the rest of this whimsical scene was ‘go way around!’ I couldn’t have the fresh blanket of snow trampled on!


As mentioned at the beginning of this exploration of “photography as art” it begins with a blank black canvas onto which James paints with light. If the environment and subject is in the darkness of night, preferably one that is moonless, artificial lighting will be needed to do the painting.

CUT to a (nice) female hand holding unexposed pieces of film: a 35mm, 2 1⁄4, and 4X5, then to the Image 41 showing the drawings with technical notes1 for CHANGING AT EAST CHOP.

CUT to Image 43 and do a quick Zoom IN to the back of the corridor, and then in a WAVY pattern ZOOM OUT again.

The diagram for CHANGING AT EAST CHOP indicates creating this photograph took a bit of technical wizardry. The environment was the old East Chop Beach Club. The diagram shows the center corridor about 100 feet long to which on either side are doors to twenty or more small changing rooms kitty-corner from each other. James enjoyed the depth of perspective on seeing this every time he visited for paying assignments, and wanted to visually play with it.

CUT to James


I thought it would be fun if a Muse could appear from each of the 10 kitty corner locations in different poses.

James shows putting forward to the camera the diagram from the ‘90’s. CUT to different aspects of the diagram.

Here’s a drawn diagram of my idea. To add accent to the poses I figured to give a different hue to each pose. Just like the painting with different colors in the Aurora series as I did later, note that colors transmit at different nanometers.

CUT to video of firing a flash with different color gels, ending with green,

Some take more; others take less light-time to transmit, and this determines the number of flashes, as noted on my diagram. Being less than perfect my exposure of the Muse using the green gel barely shows…


James rented a 90mm wide angle Rodenstock lens for his View Camera. It was placed at a low angle and secured with heavy tape to keep it from moving.

Image 42 shows the drawings with technical notes2 for CHANGING AT EAST CHOP.

CUT to a photo of the front of a View Camera showing the lens. CUT to Image 43 of the CHANGING AT EAST CHOP illusion. Start from a CU of the back and pull back again to follow the script until showing the full photograph.

The progression of multiple exposures on one piece of film started at the rear, with the muse at a door on left side, and the exposing flash, with a specific color gel, placed diagonally across one changing room closer to the camera. Each of the subsequent exposures following this process bringing the muse closer, from one side to the other, to the final 10th shot close to the camera’s position.

CUT to JAMES in a sleeping bag. CUT starry sky with TIMEPASE to dawn, sun rising.


Not shown in my notes is the 11th exposure. Getting to the 10th exposure took all evening. After, I camped out in the sleeping bag under a clear starry night out, rising early to expose for a dawn sky. Now it was completed.

CUT to JAMES addressing the camera audience with lens in hand. CUT to lens in hand. CUT to JAMES

Simple enough! Not really, it took 4 tries over several years. Three preceding attempts failed, once due to a malfunctioning rented lens and twice it didn’t come out as it should have. Remember there was no LCD screen back then for immediate results. With this shot was being made on Private Property, and each failure left me with anxiety of ever having the opportunity of doing it again.

Image 43 shows the CHANGING AT EAST CHOP illusion in pans, tilts, zooms, and in full.

You might ask why not repeated immediate tries…well, could only do it off-season, on moonless nights, with a rented lens, there were time constraints, and each effort was significant.


Whenever James is asked or has the opportunity to talk about his work the GHOST OF CHILMARK WOODS has always been among the top Illusions of interest. Its creation involved a high level of all the facets of “photography as art”; logistics, staging, and technical applications.

CUT to headlines and other materials regarding ghosts on the Vineyard, as well as backroad shots from Chilmark.

The inspiration for this photograph is the Vineyard’s reputation as being a most haunted island. Especially during the fall months when the leaves have turned to yellow, red and brown, the air is chilly air, everything is damp, and the sky is a bleak grey overcast. During this season, James would drive along the back roads and pass less travelled unpaved pathways to wonder; “Where do they lead; who might live down there?” It’s so quiet you can hear the dew drops fall, somewhat spooky, and yes, a ghostly time of year.

Image 44 shows the GHOST OF CHILMARK WOODS illusion in pans, tilts, zooms, and in full.

Image 45 shows the dirt pathway with a mysterious patch of thick ground fog (dry ice) emanating at its center.


The spooky feeling is all around the area, but a photograph needs a specific spot that best conveys it. James pre- visualized a ghost Muse shrouded in tulle and levitating across a dirt pathway to who knows where. It would be on a dreary damp fall day with trees displaying their fall colors, with a heavy layer of fallen leaves on the ground.


The important thing was to find a location offering a perfect view, while at the same time a place just off a crossroad unlikely to be disturbed by a passerby. In time found the spot.

CUT to video showing a 4X5 film holder, loading film holder under safe light (even though that’s done in total darkness). Putting holder in back of view camera, removing slide, exposing, putting slide back…the hole process will be left to history.

The plan was to make two exposures on one piece of 4X5 film, one during the daytime to capture the woods and fog covered pathway, and a night exposure to capture the ghost. To make it work the camera had to remain fixed in one spot, undisturbed for many hours, for both exposures. The only haphazard that could be left to chance would be if a deer happened upon it, and that would simply be bad luck.

Image 48 shows the list of materials needed for this photograph. (Open to suggestions if some video, animation or other visual, such as having the platform drawn by an artist into the GHOST illusion photograph, just to show how it looked and was place, which is my suggestion.)


Now it was time to check off preparations from the list. Among other things it included bringing a 12X2 foot section of a wooden dock to the location with his truck. It would- be put-on cinder blocks. It would be set up for the night exposure and be the platform on which the ghost would seem and seen to levitate across the wide pathway. James explains…

CUT to James in a dark Studio (lights out). Lights turn and a pulls a off black cloth covering him. CUT back to artist hand putting in black cloth on and around platform. REVERSE sequence to have it disappear.


Anything black in photography does not expose. I brought black cloth to drape the platform so it would not expose. This allows the details from the daylight exposure to show through. That large platform on cinder blocks is in the photograph, you just don’t see it through the magic of photography!

CUT to suggestions. Possibly A) CUT to JAMES in heavy fog trying to see his way out, or B) a fog machine…a fog machine in action, or C) more humorous stock footage of ships generating smoke screen. CUT to showing blocks of dry ice.

To get the effect of ground fog I had originally planned to hock up a rented smoke machine to a generator. This this was scratched in favor of using dry ice, which tends to cling to the ground surface. This exchange did not make things easier – there was no dry ice to be found on Island! I had to go to Boston to pick that up.

CUT to JAMES facing camera audience. CUT to photo of Boston. CUT to Ferry crossing Vineyard sound. CUT to Head Shot of Muse, Ann.

Timing was now based on having the dry ice. A well-sealed Styrofoam container of dry ice will only hold up for maybe three days before evaporating, so scheduling its pick up from Boston was critical. That in itself took ferry trips and the better part of a day. Then all the other preparations, equipment, and Muse had to be ready to go within a three-day window when the weather, that had been awful, might cooperate.


His notes indicate that October 21, 1993 was the day of the shoot, which was preceded by that trip to Boston 3 days earlier to get the dry ice. Dismal dreary wet weather that had persisted during that time finally had a lull.

CUT to tripod with camera being fixed in one spot using weighted bags., digging a hole, placing dry ice, pouring water to activate

ground surface fog. CUT to the result in the GHOST illusion. From there inserting another holder, pulling the slide, and “click.”

The View Camera, wonderfully suited for creative photography, was placed in the woods by the edge of the selected cross road in the Chilmark woods and fixed in place with a clear view of the scene to be staged. Then a small hole was dug out in the middle foreground of the pathway, into which dry ice was placed. After it was activated with hot water, he took his first daylight exposures onto several sheets of Kodak Ektachrome film in holders that had been prepared in advance of the shoot.

Repeat Image 48 shows the 3 ghosting effects cropped from the GHOST OF CHILMARK WOODS illusion in pans, tilts, zooms, and in full.

CUT to video footage of camera being camouflaged.

The first phase was completed. James camouflaged the camera and left to pick up the dock and other materials. He would return hours later at dusk to set up for the second exposure. This phase would be far more complicated, and to help he brought an assistant, Kenny Sullivan.

CUT to JAMES addressing the camera audience.

Image 49 shows notes with exposure specifications (as well as dry ice usage instructions).


Sully, as Kenny was known, worked at the Post Office. Nice fellow, but he had an affliction to drink. Drinking is one of the common ailments of the Island, but he was always reliable with his help. We shared harrowing experiences when I shot the MAGICAL GAY HEAD CLIFFS illusion. Poor fellow left us early I’ve heard.


James, with Sully’s help set the heavy dock on cinder blocks and draped it in black. After nightfall the Muse arrived and made her last preparations to walk the plank.


While she did that, James showed Sully how to work the shutter cable release attached to the View Camera, being very careful not to jar its position. This would leaveJAMES free to handle the final tricky aspects of this shoot, exposing the ghosting; creating three faint images of the ghost, followed by the final full exposure of the ghost.


In order to pull this off I had a Metz 60 CT1 flash with battery pack on each shoulder. One was set to underexpose, while the other was set to properly expose. I kneeled on the camera side close to the platform and ahead of the direction of the ghost’s movement. I aimed both flash units in the direction the ghost would be walking. Oh. you don’t see me either in this shot, do you, but dressed in black I’m the invisible super ghost you don’t see…

CUT to a graphic of the opening instructions below, like you would see in a silent movie. CUT to video of 3 weak flashes followed by a full power flash that will wash out…white out the screen.

Ready! I let the action begin. “Sully, open the camera shutter. Ann, begin walking down the plank.” James pressed three times to set off the under exposing flashes coming off of one shoulder and then set-off the full exposure from the unit on his other shoulder. Abracadabra and it’s done! Just in time before a cloudburst of pouring rain.

CUT to and DISSOLVE through a number of the 37 illusions that have not been highlighted in this script.

Image 50 (a repeat of 43) shows the GHOST OF CHILMARK WOODS illusion in pans, tilts, zooms, and in full. CUT to video of setting exposures on each Metz CT1


These are a few gems from the Illusion series, which numbered 37 in total when the last was taken around 1997. James believes his photographs in any series should be looked at like songs on CD, some you like better than others, and some become known as the hits. We each have our favorites for luckily, he’s not a one hit wonder.

THE END of Scene Seven

Image 51 shows James with V&A Curator, James Bettley. Image 52 shows letter from V&A.


James concluded years of work of the Illusion series and published a book “Illusions of Martha’s Vineyard.” He flew to London in 1997 to thank the curator at the renowned Victoria & Albert Museum. It was the first museum to accept photography in the mid-eighteen hundreds, and they included his work as part of their collection.

THE END of Scene Eight